Resident and 2-Year Old Daughter Inform Parks Commission About off-leash Dog Dangers in Fox Nature Preserve

Resident Stephen Eich, 2 year township resident, of 1261 Lake George lives with Fox Nature Preserve bordering his property. His 2-year old daughter plays outside. Mr. Eich has 15 years’ experience as a Firefighter / Paramedic, 5 years in mid-Michigan and then 10 years in Detroit areas. He is now, as he told me, “a full-time dad to raise my daughter and focus on my family and health.”

At the November 12, 2025 Parks and Recreation Commission meeting, Mr. Eich read his well-thought out remarks on safety problems in Fox Nature Preserve including gun-fire. He felt that off-leash dogs were the top problem. It is worth watching this segment on the meeting video https://videoplayer.telvue.com/player/KGL-y_dHhCluQTy7c6YoVBzzQ5eHj7Lr/media/987037starting at minute 11:30.

Mr. Eich made suggestions about improved signage placement (at entrance to trails and on trail paths) and design (pictorial in addition to words).

This led to the PRC immediately adding Mr. Eich’s issue informally to their agenda and discussing it. Director Ben McCloskey who was aware, in general, in advance, of what Mr. Eich was going to say had already scheduled a meeting for the next morning with Township Manager Joe Merucci to discuss this issue.

I commented that in addition to better signs, strong patrolling and enforcement is essential to correcting this problem. How well are 60 MPH speed-limit signs heeded in I-75 construction zones? We need to issue tickets leading to $500 fines or 90 days in jail for both, as I think our ordinances provide as penalties. (See below).

On Thursday Stephen and I received this email from Parks Director Ben McCloskey

“Afternoon Stephen & Bob,

I wanted to thank you again for taking the time to attend last night’s PRC Meeting.

I spoke with Lieutenant Dooley this morning who has agreed to increase patrol at FNP during early morning and after work hours.

My team and I have started to work on custom signage for helping to enforce the primary concerns of FNP neighbors. I thought your suggestions for signage language last night were very on point – Would you mind sharing your thoughts articulating: 1) private residence within park 2) children at play 3) no dogs off-leash?

Lastly, given the lack of specifics within current state and local ordinance, I’ve spoken with Township Manager, Joe Merucci, and asked to consult OT counsel and the Board of Trustees to potentially create its own ordinance that enforces fees and other penalties to effectively address this issue.

Thanks again for your time and concern in the general safety of our community. Please feel free to reach out to myself or the police department should you need any immediate support on this matter.

Sincerely,

Ben McLoskey”

The township has “The Code of The Charter Township of Oakland”, that organizes all of our ordinances https://ecode360.com/OA3183. There are physical copies at Township Hall outside the windows in a binder.

Code Section 299-27-12 prohibits off-leash dogs in parks

All persons walking or exercising pets in a park are required to clean up all debris resulting from the pets with the exception of leader, guide, hearing and service animals. Pets must be on a leash not exceeding 10 feet in length and under control at all times.”

Code Section 1-2 D Defines penalties for violation of above – $500 plus costs or 90 days in jail or both.

“Except as specifically provided otherwise by state law or Township ordinance, all violations of this Code are misdemeanors. Except as otherwise provided by law or ordinance, a person convicted of a violation of this Code that is a misdemeanor shall be punished by a fine not to exceed $500, and costs of prosecution, or by imprisonment for a period of not more than 90 days, or by both such fine and imprisonment. However, unless otherwise provided by law, a person convicted of a violation of this Code which substantially corresponds to a violation of state law that is a misdemeanor for which the maximum period of imprisonment is 93 days shall be punished by a fine not to exceed $500, and costs of prosecution, or by imprisonment for a period of not more than 93 days, or by both such fine and imprisonment.”

(Section 45-3C gives the Manager / Superintendent (Joe Merucci) this responsibility
To see that all laws and Township ordinances are enforced.” This is taken from our Ordinance #97, from 2002.)

Location of 1261 Lake George –

It is tax ID 10-09-100-018 in below from Oakland County Property Gateway https://gis.oakgov.com/PropertyGateway/Home.mvc

10-09-100-024 to the right (east) is Fox Nature Preserve park. Left is Clam Lake.

See excellent detailed boundary map (below) from meeting packet of 6/8/21 BOT page 80. https://ecode360.com/OA3183/document/606320958.pdf

1261 Lake George is inside small box to right of Clam Lake (faint blue dotted line) along with two other private residents. They gain access via an easement granted through the park shown in dotted green. All of Fox Nature Preserve (shown as Lost Lake Acquisition on this map) and two of the three residents were part of Bill Fox (deceased auto dealer) estate. Parks bought it with a grant from MNRTF with temporary “emergency” funding from Township Board and then sold the two former Bill Fox houses. Fox Heirs were getting ready to sell it to developers. The Township Board insisted it had authority to name the park. Otherwise it would have been an expansion of Lost Lake Park with no separate name. The legal authorities of Township Board vs. separately elected Parks Commission are in state law but unclear. https://www.legislature.mi.gov/(S(wehjt2552zy5bl551r0iep55))/documents/mcl/pdf/mcl-act-157-of-1905.pdf

For example, the law says the Township Board approves the Parks Commission budget. A few years ago they removed the line for some legal expenses from the Parks budget. That left them unable to contest the Board. Is that what the law really intended?, to remove line items or just to pass judgement on the total budget amount in the days of no defined millages for specific purposes, just one big money pot, as the City of Rochester still operates.

Study / Photos of Trails Inside Stony Creek Metropark That We May or May Not Connect to

In March 2025, I walked from my house at 1146 Bear Creek Ct. across Bear Creek Nature Park, through Oakland Farms, south on the existing safety path on the west side of Rochester to the corner of Snell and Rochester, crossed Rochester at the signal by the church and then down some possible routes to Stony Creek Metropark. I took photos of trail conditions inside the park.

I had intended to make a better edited report than the 49 pages posted below. But I never got around to it. Here it is with imperfections. This may be especially useful for those who have not been in these areas of the park. Scroll down to see all pages

Oakland Township Association Set the Wheels in Motion to Make Our Township Character What is is Now

I was surprised to learn recently that a friend had not heard of the Oakland Township Association. This non-profit organization was in play from 1970 to 1982. I heard bits and pieces of it from Alice Tomboulian and Peggy Johnson, who were heavily involved and from Chris Munk, whose father was involved. Also we heard from former Clerk Carolyn Phelps who spoke a little about it at a board meeting about 12 years ago. I always meant to research its history further, but found no time. Barbara Barber’s mother was a member. Attorney George Googasian helped with Parks land acquistion. Many others were involved who I do not know about. There were enough people that they formed various committees.

As I recall Carolyn Phelps’ comments at a Board meeting, when Avon Township, now Rochester Hills began cutting down many large old trees at Adams and Walton and similar trees were cut on one of our roads, by DTE, residents became alarmed and organized to make our Township remain more rural. Members got elected to the Board of Trustees. A Planning Commission was formed who created our first Master Plan. They lead the formation of the Zoning Ordinance, Tree Ordinance, ZBA and Parks Commission. Peggy Johnson told me that what got her involved was a Board decision that her lot was too narrow (200 feet) for her horse. Alice Tomboulian was a force to be dealt with in Parks and Recreation. Alice and Peggy and one man made the Paint Creek Trail come into being – quite a feat. (See the small plaque along trail near Paint Creek Cider Mill.)

It would be great if some author researched the entire history and wrote a book. Oakland Township Historical Society has records stored at Cranberry Lake Farm. Maybe someone on OTHS would consider it?

Pursue “Township of Excellence”?; Board should at least discuss and make a firm decision?

The Michigan Township Association has established (how?) criteria for being an excellent Township. Only about 3 of 1240 Michigan Townships have applied for this and been awarded recognition. Of course it is possible that some townships meet all the criteria but see no reason to apply, but leave it up to their residents to judge. Former Trustee Maureen Thalmann suggested in a board reports comment that we pursue this. It was never discussed in public. One Board member commented that sometimes pursuing to get a box checked may lead to “fake conformance”. I’ve seen that.

Nevertheless we are, in my view, far short of the criteria which can be seen here on the MTA website.

Click below on “HOME” below and then look for “Township of Excellence” in the “About” drop-down menu.

Home

Any Volunteers to Help Me set Up a Citizens Advisory Board?

In the previous post below I got exactly one volunteer, a board member. If we can’t form such an organization, we can’t improve in my view. We need three to incorporate at a non-profit. I make one. We need two more minimum on the way to 1% of voters being members or about 170.

In addition to this Citizens Board being advisory; it would be my intention that the Township Board ignores our advice only with great danger, as we will survey township voters to be sure our recommendations have support of a majority. Ignoring what voters want will then lead to replacement by recall or no re-election, depending on seriousness and urgency.

At the time I wrote this, I got this comment:

“Interesting concept. A much simpler approach would be to do what other Charter Townships do and have these Board positions be paid full-time positions. Up until 2000, the Township Supervisor, Clerk & Treasurer were full-time paid positions. Those people serving in these positions at that time wanted to retire, so they had the Board make them part-time positions with minimal pay. Of course our Township was quite smaller in population so this made sense.”

note – Population – Year 2020-20,067, Year 2000 – 13071

I think we should do both things. The Citizens Advisory Board is needed to perform a responsible effective watchdog role. This is necessary and to me is required in “self-government”.

Dog Safety in Our Parks

Because of frequent encounters with off-leash dogs in our parks, I take a walking stick and a 5″ hunting knife for defense. I recently added red pepper spray. Consider what safety precautions you will take.

I suffered 3 dog bites during 6 years on a Cleveland Press bike paper route from off-leash dogs who the owners said would “never bite”. So I don’t give dog owners any credibility to know what their dog will do. They are unpredictable animals.

In a March 2021 survey as part of daily walks in Bear Creek Nature Park I found 21% of dogs off-leash. See data in this Excel workbook. I stopped going to BCNP after a very scary encounter with a Rottweiler that a lady had just let off leash. I assume she did not see me.

I think our efforts to stop dog owners from taking off-leash dogs to our parks are not adequate. I would support funding a truly nice dog park in Oakland Township; not a sterile field as at Stony Creek Metropark. I think the option of a truly nice dog park with fields, woods, a stream, etc. is the only solution; although enforcement (warning tickets – first time) and education would help.

Of interest to PRC may be this collection of 25 pages from old minutes showing PRC thinking on the issue and the long-time problem at BCNP.

Here is a nice letter on the subject created by AI that does better than I could.

Leash Requirements for Dogs in Oakland Township Parks

Promoting Safety and Responsibility in Our Oakland Township Parks

Dear Oakland Township Residents:

I am writing to express the importance of keeping your dog on a leash while enjoying our township parks. As a fellow resident and frequent visitor of these beautiful public spaces, I have witnessed firsthand both the joys of responsible pet ownership and the challenges that can arise when rules are not followed.

Leashing your dog in parks is not only a township ordinance, but it is also a matter of public safety. Unleashed dogs, even those with gentle temperaments, may become unpredictable in unfamiliar environments or when encountering other people and animals. This can lead to accidental injuries, altercations between pets, and anxiety for park visitors who may be uncomfortable around dogs.

Additionally, keeping your dog on a leash helps protect local wildlife and preserves the natural beauty of our parks. Uncontrolled pets can disturb birds, squirrels, and other animals, and sometimes damage plants and landscaping that everyone works hard to maintain.

Leash laws are designed to ensure that all members of our community—young and old, pet owners and non-owners alike—can share these public spaces safely and peacefully. By keeping your dog leashed, you demonstrate respect for your neighbors and set a positive example for others.

Let us all work together to maintain our parks as safe, welcoming places . Please remember to always bring a sturdy leash when visiting, and ensure your dog is under control at all times. Thank you for your cooperation and commitment to our community’s well-being.

1-Help Us Get More Readers; 2-Know a Good, Free Email Distribution Method?

The Oakland Township Sentinel is sent to about 470 email addresses. Also 20 direct subscribers went to our website and arranged to get it (also free) as soon as a post is made. We had 17,028 registered voters in Oakland Township at the time of the November 2024 election. So we reach, at most, about 3% of voters.

If you can help spread the word among your friends and neighbors, it would be appreciated.

It’s easiest for us if they to the website and arrange to subscribe. Our new Outlook in Word 365 “chokes” on 470 emails at once so we divided it up into 13 separate distributions to get it out. We can send two of these at once. That is time consuming, and even with that we can’t feed them too fast. We have to wait until the first batch of about 80 has successfully gone out before sending the next.

If anyone can recommend a good free service for sending mass emails, please contact me. There is lots on-line, but a recommendation would be golden.

Bob Yager at yagerra@comcast.net

Oakland Township Trustee John Casadei Invites any Residents, Staff or Employees to meet with three Trustees every third Monday, 3-5 PM, to tell them “what is important to them”. First Meeting is November 17th

At the October 28th, Board of Trustees meeting, Trustee John Casadei made these 2-minute remarks. See them at minute 1:09:57 on the video. I believe an accurate and complete transcript is below. I wholeheartedly applaud this idea.

Trustee Casadei said –

“I’d like to start on a regular basis an informal open Trustee meeting, to be held the third Monday of every month 3 to 5 PM here in the Board room at Township Hall. The first meeting is scheduled for November 17th with three of the newer Trustees, myself, Trustee Campbell and Trustee Langlois. I’m hopeful that we will rotate Trustees as their schedules permit.

Having been on the Board of Review for ten years, I thought it was very valuable to have these informal meetings and listen to residents from every corner of the Township. It was informative, educational, and quite honestly, I think it lead to better decisions.

I’m hopeful that this gives residents, business owners, staff, or employees an avenue where they can come in – no video, no podiums, no mikes, no three minute timer, just come in and tell us what is important to them. Get to know us;  we are your neighbors, we are residents. I think the better we communicate and have dialogue between us the better this township will be. So, I’m hopeful that this is the start of something we will do on a regular basis.

This is Trustee John Casadei’s first term as a Trustee. You may recall that this is his 2024 election campaign signs said “Closing Zoning Loopholes”